Catsup Substitution

1 cup tomato sauce
plus
1/2 cup sugar
plus
2 tablespoons vinegar
can be substituted for 1 cup catsup for use in cooking.

Pepperoncini Substitution

pickled cherry peppers
can be substituted for pepperoncini.

Cornichon Substitution

sweet gherkins (sweeter)
or
dill pickle slices
can be substituted for cornichon.

Cocktail Sauce Substitution

1 cup ketchup
plus
1/4 cup prepared horseradish
plus
1 tablespoon lemon juice
can be substituted for cocktail sauce

Creole Mustard Substitution

whole-grain mustard
or
hot mustard
or
Dijon mustard
plus
a bit of horseradish
can be substituted for creole mustard.

Chili Sauce Substitution

Chili sauce
1 cup tomato sauce
plus
1/4 cup brown sugar
plus
2 tablespoons vinegar
plus
1/4 teaspoon cinnamon
plus
dash of ground cloves
plus
dash of allspice
can be substituted for 1 cup chili sauce

Mustard, Prepared Substitution

1/2 teaspoon dry mustard
plus
2 teaspoons vinegar
can be substituted for 1 tablespoon prepared mustard.